Mark’s Myth Busters and Little-Known Facts

Tree Planting and Care Tree Diseases and Pests Tree Physiology Planting Design Urban Aesthetics and Design
Tree Planting and Care
Fertilizing Trees

To survive and grow, trees need 18 essential elements:

  • carbon (C)
  • oxygen (O)
  • hydrogen (H)
  • molybdenum (Mo)
  • iron (F)
  • copper (Cu)
  • cadmium (Ca)
  • sulfur (S)
  • magnesium (Mg)
  • manganese (Mn)
  • boron (B)
  • chlorine (Cl)
  • nitrogen (N)
  • phosphorus (P)
  • potassium (K)
  • zinc (Zn)
  • nickel (Ni)
  • cobalt (Co)
 

Essential elements are not plant “food.” Trees do not obtain energy directly from these elements; rather, trees get energy through photosynthesis - a process that converts light energy (sunlight) to chemical energy (sugar).

Fertilizing a tree by “feeding” it fertilizer will not necessarily make it healthier; in fact, it may actually do harm, such as making it more susceptible to pests. Fertilize a tree only after a thorough diagnosis and evaluation by an International Society of Arboriculture certified arborist to determine an appropriate formulation.

Tree Shelters

Tree shelters are sometimes used for revegetation plantings. These translucent plastic cylinders are placed primarily around deciduous tree seedlings to provide a micro-climate of protection. A recent study on the effects of plastic tree shelters conducted by Auburn University, Alabama, found that shelters

  • increase survivability and growth height, but lessen biomass (due to decreased photosynthesis and root growth)
  • seem to benefit selected species and selected planting sites, but have no beneficial effect on others
  • force plant growth by increasing growth height, resulting in weak, thinner stems
  • prolong the active growing season, which may decrease cold hardiness

MPA is not convinced that the extra expense of installing and then removing shelters is worth their use.

Tree Stakes

Tree stakes should not be used unless the tree proves to be unstable after installation. Stakes need only to be about 60 cm high when installed. Ensure that the tree saddle used (no "piece-of-wire-and-garden hose" please) enables the tree trunk to move within the saddle. Trees respond to stimulus and need this freedom to develop a properly tapered trunk. It is also important to remove any tree supports after the root ball has stabilized, generally after one season of growth.

Tree Paint
Tree paint should not be used over freshly pruned branch wounds. Studies have shown that tree paint, also called wound dressing, hinders the tree’s natural ability to compartmentalize the cut and form a scab. Its use may also provide a safe hiding place for insects.
Tree Diseases and Pests back to top

Emerald Ash Borer

Emerald Ash Borer (EAB) will likely continue its easterly spread across Ontario. A study conducted by Ohio State University found that EAB seems to prefer feeding on Green Ash and White Ash. Manchurian Ash, an ash species from Asia (the native habitat of EAB), seems to be least preferred. Manchurian Ash may have developed EAB defence mechanisms. While MPA is reducing the numbers of native ash trees it is specifying in anticipation of the spread of EAB, we will start to include some Manchurian Ash in our specifications.
Tree Physiology back to top
Antigravity Plumbing

Trees are an engineering marvel. How does a tree lift water from its roots to its top at a rate of up to 46 metres per hour and 380 litres a day? The job is done by a series of inert pipes called the xylem. How the xylem actually does this is not fully understood.

Equally amazing is that, pound for pound, trees and other plants need much more water to survive than animals do. For example, a sunflower must take up 17 times more water each day than a human of comparable weight would need. Of course, some plants do not need as much water as others, because they have built-in mechanisms that reduce transpiration rates or leakage through their leaf pores.

Growth Cycles
Different parts of woody plants grow at different times of the growing season. Deciduous trees go through a wake-up period, or dehardening, early in the spring. Roots start to grow followed by bud break, shoot and leaf elongation – all powered by stored energy within the tree. After the leaves have opened (similar to the unfurling of a solar panel array on a newly launched space satellite), energy created by photosynthesis powers bud development for next year, and trunk and branch diameter growth. Just before the tree goes dormant in the fall, new branchlets harden off and a flurry of root growth reoccurs.
Spiral Growth
Have you ever noticed that the grain of a tree grows in a spiral around the trunk? This is why the crack caused by a lightening strike spirals up the tree. Studies have shown that this spiral growth allows water from each individual root to reach every branch on the tree. The spiral grain in the wood allows trees to bend more easily in high winds without breaking.
Street Lighting
& Street Trees
Security lighting and street lighting affects tree growth, flowering, and dormancy rates.
Air Conditioning Trees
Trees can reduce the urban heat island by 12 degrees C. A tree can transpire about 300 liters of water per day, comparable to the cooling effect of five average room air conditioners with a capacity of 2,500 Kcal per hour running 20 hours per day.
Earth Worms & Trees

Did you know that the earth worms found in the northern half of North America are actually alien?

Ten thousand years ago, during the last Ice Age, all the native worm species were killed or driven south ahead of the ice sheets. As the glaciated landscape slowly became reforested, it did so without earth worms. The earth worms that we find today arrived later from southern North America, Europe, and Asia along with humans who settled North America after the glaciers retreated.

Our perception of earth worms is that they are a good component of a healthy soil. We know that they decompose dead organic matter and help aerate the soil. But read on...

In a native forest WITHOUT earth worms, the soil surface has a deep layer (up to 100 mm) of decaying duff populated by fungi. This duff material may take up to five years to decompose. In the process, this decomposition recycles as much as 80% of the forest nitrogen in a form easily used by trees: ammonium.

In a native forest WITH earthworms, the decay process speeds up. In fact, this process can take as little as one year, mixing the soil together and flooding it with ammonium. Bacteria convert the ammonium into nitrate, which is more difficult for the trees to use. Much more easily leached from the soil by rainfall than ammonium, nitrate may, in turn, lead to ground water quality problems.

How does the absence of this deep duff layer affect the growth of typical spring ephemerals such as trilliums, trout lilies, and Canada mayflower? Some ecologists suggest that these populations have declined and may disappear altogether. Other experts suggest that the species composition of forests is changing in favour of small-seeded trees over large-seeded ones in the absence of the deep duff layer.

MPA suggests the absence of the duff layer may be contributing to the spread of invasive exotic weeds such as garlic mustard into urban and near-urban forests.

Urban Forest Regeneration
Urban forests are subject to the effects of trampling, which may impede growth of new seedlings. Old, decaying stumps provide microclimate for seedlings and may also act as a physical barrier to trampling. When forestry practice dictates the removal of dead or unsafe trees, leaving a high stump (greater than 150 cm) provides an enhanced microclimate for seedling growth while at the same time acting as an effective physical barrier to trampling.
Planting Design back to top
Good Design & Restraint

One of the indicators of good design is restraint. Believe it or not, the best landscape planting designs are very simple, with only a limited number of plant species massed into large drifts. An old design rule is: KISS (keep it simple, silly). Bad design and construction is just as expensive as good design and construction… so do it right the first time!

Landscape designs go through different design styles and trends, just like clothing and interior design. MPA strives for a classic, timeless design style, as opposed to the "flavour of the month/year" trend. Timeless design is simple, elegant, and restrained.

Plant Numbers
The greater the number of plants used in a given area, the quicker the spaces between them will fill in. "Closing the gap" will help to shade out weeds and conserve moisture. MPA thinks that massed plants always look better then scattered individual plants.
Native Versus
Non-native Plants
While it is important to use native, local genotypes of native plants as much as possible, sometimes a non-native plant is better suited to the site conditions and the overall objectives of the landscape plan. MPA supports the adage "the right plant in the right location."
"Special Mix "
-Type Soils

You've heard of "special mix"-type soils, sold by many nurseries. But unless you are growing annual bedding plants, stay away from it - as the ING guy says, “save your money.” Special mix-type soils are a mixture of top soil (a resource that is becoming scarce and valuable, like oil and gold), spaghnum peat moss (which nature takes 1,000 years to make), and manure or compost. You do not need it to grow most plants!

MPA will never specify "special mix"-type soil.

Sphagnum Peat Moss

Sphagnum peat moss is dead organic material that has taken nature 1,000 years to produce. Despite what you may be told, it has no redeeming value to the landscape industry. Sphagnum peat moss is sterile, has few or no plant "nutrients," may reduce soil pH, and will not readily absorb water if it ever dries out (it will shed water instead). Well-rotted leaves or compost and clean, sharp sand are far superior soil amendments.

MPA will never specify the use of sphagnum peat moss.

Mulch

Mulch can be your best friend.

Place mulch 75 mm to 100 mm deep. At this depth, it will reduce weed growth and keep moisture in the soil. As it decomposes, it returns essential elements back into the soil. The trick is to use shredded conifer bark mulch. Don't bother with wood chips, as this type of mulch will not knit together and may decay too fast. Be sure to keep mulch away from plant stems and trunks – avoid a ‘mulch volcano’ – to prevent stem rot.

Irrigation Systems
MPA does not believe that it is wise to use irrigation systems for its plant installations. While it is important to keep newly installed plants watered for the first year, the use of precious water to keep landscape plants alive artificially is not something we wish to encourage. We believe it is better to select plants suitable for the growing conditions of the site.
Urban Aesthetics and Design back to top
History of Urban Form

Have you ever wondered why suburban landscapes all look the same?

This did not happen by accident. Colston Burrell, in the Spring 1997 issue of Wildflower, pp. 19 to 21, identified six suburban landscape characteristics:

  • An unobstructed view to the front of the house
    A clear view of the front of the house and an unambiguous path to the front door is a holdover from the era of the great estates of Europe.
  • Manicured turf on the front yard
    All great estates also had vast expanses of manicured lawns. A well-manicured lawn - a powerful and enduring landscape feature in North America - was intended to signify care, neighbourliness, and stewardship.
  • Foundation plantings
    Foundation plantings did not exist prior to the advent of suburbia in the 1930s. They were initially used to hide the foundation pillars of houses that did not have basements or cellars.
  • Street trees and a median, and one or more shade trees in the front yard
    Shade trees in the front yards of the great estates were used to frame the views of the façade, as decoration, to provide shade, and to draw the eye.
  • Flower beds
    Flowers provide colour in an otherwise monochromatic green landscape. Because flower beds need human intention and care, they symbolize that the homeowner cares about the neighbourhood.
Manicured Lawns

Paul F. J. Eagles, a professor in the University of Waterloo's Faculty of Applied Health Sciences, theorizes that the icon of the manicured lawn developed in Victorian England. Rural England at the time of Queen Victoria was a landscape of green, rolling hills where grazing sheep closely cropped the pasture grasses. Abundant English rainfall and nutrient-rich sheep droppings kept the grasses deep green.

To the poor, landless immigrants who flooded Canada and the United States during this time, the rolling green hills of the English estate were a symbol of wealth and social power. As North America became urbanized, the new urbanites wanted to retain this powerful symbol by having their own small sheep pasture around their "estate." With a little help over the next century from organizations such as the United States Department of Agriculture, the Garden Clubs of America, the United States Golf Association (as well as soldiers returning from the World Wars, and the marketing of lawn care products), the icon of the lush, green lawn became firmly entrenched in America.

Street Trees

In early New England, during the 17th century, street trees in settlements were perceived as dangerous because they provided hiding places for aboriginal attackers. Also, the village green needed to be open for militia manoeuvres and for herding cattle. Early subdivision development in the 1940s and 1950s did not give much thought to street trees and tended to use open fields.

Man & Nature
Many empirical studies have found a definite link between human physical and mental health, and trees and nature. Contact with nature can calm anxiety and reduce stress. Trees evoke feelings of containment, comfort, and protection because they reduce urban spaces to human scale.
Visual Impact of Trees

The visual impact of a street tree lies in its crown volume. A tree must be large enough to give immediate shade; trees should be planted in sufficient numbers to create visual continuity. Therefore, plant either a few large trees or many smaller ones.

Can we afford to wait 50 to 100 years for a street tree to mature, in order to gain the right scale and visual effect? Will a tree planted today be alive in 50 years?

Urban Beautification

How often have you heard landscaping being equated with "beautifying" the urban environment? Saying this implies that trees, shrubs, and "flowers" are planted as add-ons, to make the urban environment "beautiful" or to "soften" the city.

Plants should not mask inept urban design or architecture; rather, they should be an intrinsic part of the urban structure. Plants can live without people, but can people live without plants?

Perceptions of Safety

Crime and social conflict is a concern in urban open spaces. Empirical studies have shown that physical features of an open space environment may influence perception of safety.

Long sight lines, open grassy areas, and water are associated with feelings of safety; on the other hand, dense vegetation, graffiti, and litter decrease perceived safety. Dense, unmaintained vegetation is perceived as scenic, but unsafe. Open athletic fields are viewed as safe but not very attractive. Open spaces with an overhead tree canopy but little vegetation at eye level to block views are perceived as both safe and scenic. Perceived safety is also enhanced when landscape plantings do not block the visibility of building entrances.

Graffiti

Graffiti, also known as tagging, occurs in areas that lack an identifiable owner, or do not exhibit some clue that someone is looking after the area – e.g., derelict, abandoned buildings or open spaces are often tagged.

Graffiti breeds graffiti; therefore, remove all traces as soon as it happens. Painting over it only provides a clean canvas and will only invite more graffiti. Maintain all facades and edges of buildings and open spaces to show that someone "owns" the space and cares for it.

Futility of Permanence

Nothing lasts for ever.

Niall Kirkwood, in his book Weathering and Durability in Landscape Architecture, states that time alters a built landscape by the direct effect it has on the landscape itself. You can attempt to change this alteration through regular and persistent maintenance and reconstruction, producing a static piece of built work. This, however, is also a form of change.

Kirwood suggests that the effect of time can be registered, or shown, by deliberately proposing built forms that will fail or will have a restricted or limited life. Ideas about change come about from the selection and juxtaposition of materials, the methods of working the materials and their assembly, and the relationship and sequence of joints and junctions in materials.

Weathering, according to Michael Blier, ASLA, is defined as “the product of change that occurs as a result of the interaction of similar or dissimilar materials or actions to, or upon, one another that results in the creation of a third condition. This third condition is less predictable and far less stable than the original materials.”

It is sometimes difficult for our clients to understand that once the landscape is installed, it will immediately begin to change. Plants grow and respond to environmental conditions, and hard materials and finishes will begin to weather and/or degrade. This rate of change will be governed by issues of maintenance and accountability.

Public landscapes are much more subject to the variables of changing stewardship than private landscapes. Executive officers, managers, maintenance staff, and board members/governing councilors change. Each change represents a possible loss of "institutional memory" of why and how that landscape evolved. Maintenance budgets are often reduced, and neglect sets in.

Street Furniture

Placement of street furniture such as benches is very important. Street furniture can be used to channel pedestrian flow and to encourage desirable behaviours.

Have you ever sat on a bench and, for some reason, felt uncomfortable? Maybe the bench itself was not comfortable to sit on. Chances are that the landscape architect chose that style of bench because the streetscape was designed to discourage you from lingering.

On the other hand, some seating areas encourage you to relax and enjoy yourself. One way to encourage lingering is to locate the bench in an alcove just back from the main sidewalk traffic flow, so that when seated, your back is facing a wall or shrub bed and you are facing outwards towards the street. This is known as the "gun-fighters position." The bench proportions fit you like a glove, the sun is shinning, you have some time to kill, and life is good – all by design!

Destructive Aspects of Cherry Trees
A word of caution - do not park a vehicle under a cherry tree. Ornamental cherry tree sap has been known to lift off automotive paints.
Tree Planting and Care Tree Diseases and Pests Tree Physiology Planting Design Urban Aesthetics and Design

back to top